Title: Limits of professional secrecy
Subtitle: Medical confidentiality in England and Germany in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries
Authors: Pranghofer, Sebastian  
Maehle, Andreas Holger
Language: en
Issue Date: 2006
Document Type: Article
Journal / Series / Working Paper (HSU): Interdisciplinary Science Reviews 
Volume: 31
Issue: 3
Page Start: 231
Page End: 244
Publisher Place: London
Among patients as well as doctors it is commonly held that confidentiality has been the foundation of the therapeutic relationship since the introduction of the Hippocratic oath. Nevertheless, medical confidentiality is a controversial issue, for example in current debates on HIV/AIDS, especially with regard to the question whether sexual contacts of patients infected with HIV should be warned by doctors. Consequentialist arguments are used to justify a breach of confidence to protect other people's health, as well as to defend absolute secrecy to maintain mutual trust between patient and doctor. This article discusses the history of the debates on medical confidentiality from the nineteenth century onwards in England and Germany. Comparing the debates in these two countries shows that the issue was not confined to national borders. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the debates depended not merely on ethical arguments, but were strongly influenced by public health policies, in particular regarding venereal disease prevention, by legislation, politics and the status of the medical profession. Differences in legislation and in the social standing of the medical profession in England and Germany in particular distinguish the development of the debates in the two countries. © 2006 Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining.
Organization Units (connected with the publication): Geschichte der frühen Neuzeit u.b.B. der Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte 
URL: https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/33749622755
ISSN: 03080188
DOI: 10.1179/030801806X113766
Appears in Collections:Publications of the HSU Researchers

Show full item record

CORE Recommender


checked on May 24, 2022

Google ScholarTM




Items in openHSU are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.